Assessing the Hospitality Readiness of Mainstream Voice Assistants

Press enter to search
Close search
Open Menu

Assessing the Hospitality Readiness of Mainstream Voice Assistants

By Bradley Metrock - 06/03/2019
Google Assistant answers twice as many questions correctly as Alexa, according to hospitality industry research by Score Publishing.

Voice tech – such as Amazon’s Alexa and Google’s Assistant – are already making an impact within the hospitality industry. Companies such as Marriott, Expedia, Pizza Hut, Uber, Hyatt, Kayak, Sonic and many, many others are taking the necessary steps to meet customers where they are: using their voice to conversationally engage with technology and therefore with brands.

A recent study completed by Nashville-based Score Publishing compared all five of the major voice assistants against each other in a battery of 75 hospitality-oriented questions.

The objective? Determine which voice assistants, and corresponding voice-first ecosystems, are best equipped to serve the needs of both businesses and consumers in the hospitality sectors: restaurants, hotels, travel and more.

Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple's Siri, Microsoft Cortana and Samsung Bixby were put to the test, responding to queries ranging from "I want to book a hotel room" to "What restaurants near me have a kid's menu?" to "What airlines will take me to New York City?"

Voice and Hospitality – Where We’re At
The full results of this study will be released Tuesday morning, June 4, as part of
The Voice of Hospitality Summit taking place in Dallas. But here are some key findings:

  • Google Assistant led the pack, answering a stunning 93 percent of the questions correctly, including 100 percent of the restaurant-oriented battery of questions. Second place was Microsoft's Cortana, with 87 percent of questions answered correctly. Siri had 68 percent correct, while Samsung's Bixby and Amazon's Alexa had 41 percent and 40 percent correct, respectively.
  • This means both Google Assistant, as well as Microsoft's Cortana, answered twice as many questions correctly as both Alexa and Bixby. Cortana's integration into Alexa, as part of a much-publicized partnership between Amazon and Microsoft, may mean that Cortana can help some of Alexa's current shortfalls within these sectors.
  • Collectively, the five major voice assistants were able to answer 72 percent of restaurant queries, 66 percent of hotel queries, and 59 percent of travel queries. This is significantly better than voice assistant performance we've seen in other sectors – for example, publishing.
  • At the heart of both Alexa and Bixby's hospitality deficiency is a failure to adequately handle brand-related queries. Out of 75 hospitality queries in this study, 26 of them mentioned specific brands, from McDonalds to Hilton to Ruth's Chris to Airbnb and others. Both Alexa and Bixby got eight of these 26 queries correct (31 percent) while Google Assistant soared, answering 25 of 26 correctly and only missing one. The takeaway here is that brands need to be cognizant of this shortcoming within Amazon and Samsung's nascent voice ecosystems until they are able to address the shortfall.
  • Each of the five voice assistants, even Google Assistant, had its share of oddities that we uncovered. Asking Alexa "Where can I get carryout right now?" results in receiving a list of movies currently playing at a theater near you. And asking Siri, "I want to book a vacation," results in Siri summoning the iBooks app and looking for books on vacations.

The Lesson?
For major brands, the clear path to addressing the shortfalls shown in our research is to own their own voice experiences across all platforms, and marketing those effectively to users. For smaller brands and organizations, such as regionally-owned hotel franchises or smaller restaurant chains, compelling and value-added voice experiences can dramatically increase marketing lift and number of customers aware of your brand and coming through the door. The best thing an organization can do is to identify an internal champion, or an external partner, find one particular use case that can be implemented with voice, and begin experimenting on how the technology fits your organization.

All in all, the major voice assistants are more ready to help hospitality-oriented businesses than they are prepared to serve other sectors we've examined so far this year. But there's still a lot of work to be done. And hospitality itself – restaurants, hotels and travel – represents one of the greatest, if not the single greatest, opportunity within all of voice-first technology for enterprising companies and entrepreneurs paying attention to the ever-shifting landscape.

Bradley Metrock is CEO of Nashville-based 
Score Publishing. Metrock founded podcast network VoiceFirst.FM, hosts the popular show This Week In Voice, published the audiobook Perspectives on Gender in #VoiceFirst Technology, produces VoiceFirst Events – including The Voice of Hospitality Summit (June 4, 2019, in Dallas) – and founded the industry association VoiceFirst.Community. He has been quoted by organizations as diverse as Mayo Clinic to Voicebot.AI to Forbes, and is cited as a top voice and AI thought leader.